# TRAI’s new paper about data pricing is boring. We made it fun (HT Tech) > This latest paper is a Snooze Central, but it raises some pretty important questions about the future of a neutral internet in India. # TRAI’s new paper about data pricing is boring. We made it fun ## This latest paper is a Snooze Central, but it raises some pretty important questions about the future of a neutral internet in India. Dec 11 2015, 18:42 IST ![Follow on Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/follow-us-facebook.png) ![Follow on Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/follow-us-facebook-hover.png) ![Share](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/Share.png) ![Share](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/Shareclicked.png) ![Share on WhatsApp](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/whatsapp.png) ![Share on WhatsApp](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/whatsapp-hover.png) ![Share on Twitter](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/twitter.png) ![Share on Twitter](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/twitter-hover.png) ![Share on Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/facebook.png) ![Share on Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/facebook-hover.png) ![Bookmark](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/Bookmark.png) ![Bookmarked](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/Bookmarked.png) ![image caption](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/rf/image_size_800x600/HT/p2/2015/12/11/Pictures/binary-picture-display-illustration-facebook-posing-showing_686fd7da-9fbc-11e5-87cb-5268f82dcaeb.jpg) Zero-rating is essentially telecom industry jargon for data that a consumer doesn’t pay for directly but is somehow subsidised by an operator or a content provider. Facebook’s Free Basics program uses zero-rating to let users access certain parts of the internet for free. (REUTERS) ![Author Photo](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/HTTech-new-circle-logo.png) ### By PRANAV DIXIT If you're still following the net neutrality debate in this country, you will have heard that TRAI, India's telecom regulator, just released yet another consultation paper about the topic. This one clocks in at just 11 pages compared to April's tome, which was a mind-numbing 118 pages and made for killer bedtime reading (Sample this: "Therefore, M.1079 recommendations, basically based on G.1010, are applicable especially to the IMT-2000 mobile networks for ensuring end to end QoS based on user experience.") This latest paper is still Snooze Central, but it raises some pretty important questions about the future of a neutral internet in India (Update: TRAI says that this paper isn't really about net neutrality at all). We trawled through it so you don't have to — we love our jobs — and here are some questions we know you want answers to. Also read click here. What is this consultation paper about? The paper focuses specifically on differential pricing for data, which is exactly what it sounds like — charging customers different prices for access to different websites and services. If mobile operators had their way, you would get a separate bill for using WhatsApp, another one for watching YouTube videos, yet another one for making a Skype call — and pay nothing at all for using Facebook because guess what, Papa Zuck struck a deal. Is differential pricing the same as zero-rating? Zero-rating is a kind of differential pricing. Zero-rating is essentially telecom industry jargon for data that a consumer doesn't pay for directly but is somehow subsidised by an operator or a content provider. Facebook's Free Basics program (formerly Internet.org), which provides access to a Facebook-approved section of the internet to people in 19 countries, strikes zero-rating deals with mobile operators to provide free data to consumers. In India, Reliance, which was the first operator that Free Basics was exclusive to, claimed that over a million Indians came online through the program. Zero-rating isn't necessarily evil, but it can severely impact competition in the market by putting smaller players, who can't pay service providers to zero-rate their content, at a disadvantage. What's TRAI saying in this paper? Don't use big words, please. TRAI asks four questions to "concerned stakeholders" aka you and your mobile operator in this paper. We've picked them up verbatim from the actual paper, so some big words and bad grammar are inevitable. 1. Should TSPs (telecom service providers) be allowed to have differential pricing for data usage for accessing different websites, applications or platforms? 2. If differential pricing for data usage is permitted, what measures should be adopted to ensure that the principles of non-discrimination, transparency, affordable internet access, competition and market entry, and innovation are addressed? 3. Are there alternative methods/technologies/business models, other than differentiated tariff plans, available to achieve the objective of providing free internet access to consumers? If yes, please suggest/describe these methods/technologies/business models. Also, describe the potential benefits and disadvantages associated with such methods/technologies/business models. 4. Is there any other issue that should be considered in the present consultation on differential pricing for data services? Ugh. Just give me the TL;DR version . Basically, TRAI is trying to kick start a debate about zero-rating and its various pros and cons in the India. Wait, didn't they already talk about zero-rating in the first consultation paper? Remember we said that the first paper was 118 pages? Zero-rating was just one of the issues that it touched upon. This particular paper focuses only on zero-rating and tries to have a more nuanced discussion on the topic. "[This paper] is written in a much more balanced manner than the last one," says net neutrality Saviour-in-Chief and Medianama majordomo Nikhil Pahwa. "It appears reasonable and not draconian." Yes, but what's the point of doing it now? If we had to guess, we would say… who're we kidding, we have no idea. Maybe TRAI thinks zero-rating didn't get enough press the last time. Maybe they finally woke up to everyone calling out Facebook for Free Basics. Maybe they actually do care about your views (and your mobile operator's views) on zero-rating. Or maybe some officious bureaucrat at TRAI simply gets a kick out of releasing consultation papers. "You can't second guess the regulator's intent," says Pahwa. But I remember I wrote in to TRAI when this happened the last time! You and a million other Indians.Your opinion on the subject has been heard loud and clear. Your email address has probably been leaked. In an ideal world, TRAI shouldn't negate those million emails it received just because it decided to release a new consultation paper. In an ideal world. So what's next? If you want to write in to TRAI again — and you should — send an email to advisorfea1@trai.gov.in by December 30, 2015. (Update: Your mail may bounce back). You can also call +91-11-23230752, where a friendly TRAI officer will be happy to hear exactly what you think of zero-rating and net neutrality in India, and make sure your opinion is heard by someone important. Catch all the Latest Tech News, Mobile News, Laptop News, Gaming news, Wearables News , How To News, also keep up with us on Whatsapp channel,Twitter, Facebook, Google News, and Instagram. For our latest videos, subscribe to our YouTube channel. 11 Dec, 09:40 IST 71,589,384,536,234 NEXT ARTICLE BEGINS ![View all](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/view-all-icon.png) ## Tips & Tricks ![Ghibli-style art](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/img/2025/03/28/414x233/ChatGPT_Ghibli_style_images_1743161814450_1743161814596.jpg) ### How to turn your photos into Ghibli-style art with ChatGPT for free: Step-by-step guide ![How to create an invitation using iPhone’s new Apple Invites app- Step-by-step guide](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/img/2025/02/14/414x233/invites_1738728829564_1739543695649.png) ### How to create an invitation using iPhone’s new Apple Invites app- Step-by-step guide ![Apple TV app arrives on Android phones and tablets: What you get and how to install it](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/img/2025/02/13/414x233/unnamed_1739426557335_1739426567634.jpg) ### Apple TV app arrives on Android phones and tablets: What you get and how to install it ![Vodafone Idea OTT plans](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Vodafone Idea users can now stream 17 OTT apps with one subscription: Here's how ![Android data transfer methods](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### How to transfer data from one Android to another using Google backup, USB-C cable, and more ## Editor’s Pick ![iPhone 16e launched with A18 chip, Apple AI—bringing flagship power on a budget: Check specs, price](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### iPhone 16e launched in India: All details about the new budget mobile from Apple ![DeepSeek was founded in China with only a fraction of the budget of the top AI companies in the US.](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### DeepSeek AI: How it works, who’s behind it, how it’s different from ChatGPT, and its big US market impact explained ![iPhone 17 Air likely to get this feature that iPhone 17 Pro models may miss out on](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### iPhone 17 Air likely to get this feature that iPhone 17 Pro models may miss out on ![Google Whisk AI explained: How remixing works, availability, and how it differs from Gemini](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Google Whisk AI explained: How remixing works, availability, and how it differs from Gemini ![iOS 18.4 beta arriving soon: Know why it is the biggest iPhone update](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### iOS 18.4 beta arriving soon: Know why it is the biggest iPhone update ## Trending Stories ![Airtel 5G SIM card will now be delivered in 10 minutes with Blinkit- How to order](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Airtel 5G SIM card will now be delivered in 10 minutes with Blinkit- How to order ![Infinix Note 50s 5G+](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Infinix Note 50s 5G+ set to launch in India with 64MP camera and MediaTek Dimensity 7300 SoC ![Xiaomi X Pro QLED Series sale starts in India: Check price, availability, and more](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Xiaomi X Pro QLED Series sale starts in India: Check price, availability, and more ![Apple Intelligence AI training](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Apple plans to train AI using your on-device data without accessing personal content or emails: Report ![CMF Buds 2](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### CMF Buds 2 key features and price revealed ahead of April 28 launch: Details inside keep up with tech ![Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/tech-facebook.png) ![Twitter](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/tech-twitter.png) ![WhatsApp](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/tech-whatsApp.png) ![Facebook](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/tech-facebook.png) ## Gaming ![Check out these five gaming monitors under ₹20,000,](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Top 5 gaming monitors under ₹20000 you should consider ![gaming consoles](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Grab gaming consoles at discounted rates during Amazon Great Indian Festival: Up to 72% off ![Pokémon GO Wild Area 2025](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Pokémon GO Wild Area 2025 to bring Grimmsnarl family, Shiny Hatenna, and global challenges ![Shade Silver](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Shade Silver free on Steam for a limited time: Here’s how to get it ![Call of duty](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/ht-tech-bg-img-90-66.png) ### Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 skips Switch 2 at launch, release date and price leak ![View all](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/view-all-icon.png) ## Trending News ### Airtel 5G SIM card will now be delivered in 10 minutes with Blinkit- How to order ![Airtel 5G SIM card will now be delivered in 10 minutes with Blinkit- How to order](https://images.livemint.com/static/static/1x1_img.gif) ### Infinix Note 50s 5G+ set to launch in India with 64MP camera and MediaTek Dimensity 7300 SoC ![Infinix Note 50s 5G+](https://images.livemint.com/static/static/1x1_img.gif) ### Xiaomi X Pro QLED Series sale starts in India: Check price, availability, and more ![Xiaomi X Pro QLED Series sale starts in India: Check price, availability, and more](https://images.livemint.com/static/static/1x1_img.gif) ### Apple plans to train AI using your on-device data without accessing personal content or emails: Report ![Apple Intelligence AI training](https://images.livemint.com/static/static/1x1_img.gif) ### CMF Buds 2 key features and price revealed ahead of April 28 launch: Details inside ![CMF Buds 2](https://images.livemint.com/static/static/1x1_img.gif) ## Trending Gadgets Mobiles Laptops Tablets ![HT Tech](https://images.hindustantimes.com/tech/static/revamp/images/png/HT_tech-new.gif) - https://tech.hindustantimes.com/tech/news/decoded-what-trai-s-latest-paper-about-zero-rating-is-all-about-story-RhvyVx6OkbgsTkJlKo8vXP.html